New York’s Proposed Leachate Rule Could Leave Millions of Gallons of Contaminated “Garbage Water” Untreated

New York’s proposed landfill leachate treatment rule will require certain active landfills to treat leachate before it is discharged into sewage treatment plants or into surface water. However, the regulation contains important exemptions. In addition to currently closed landfills, the proposed rule also carves out an exemption for currently active landfills that will close within two years of the new rule taking effect. Even where a landfill hasn’t reached capacity, DEC has left the door open for operators to choose closure rather than comply with the new treatment rules. (see link, page 20) 

When a landfill is closed, existing landfill regulations require it to be covered with an impermeable cap that prevents precipitation from infiltrating through the trash. The volume of leachate produced by a properly capped landfill declines over time. Nonetheless, inactive landfills can continue producing leachate for decades after closure, making this exemption a significant gap in the proposed rule’s coverage.

Some of New York’s largest leachate generators would be affected if DEC leaves the exemption for recently closed landfills in place.

  1. The City of Albany landfill will reach capacity in fall of 2027.  From 2019-2023, the landfill produced an average of 24,086,437 gallons of leachate per year, the 7th largest volume in NYS. This leachate picks up contaminants from 10,473,637 tons of municipal solid waste, asbestos waste, ash, construction & demolition debris, industrial waste, petroleum contaminated soil, sewage treatment plant sludge, and other materials.
  2. The Ontario County Landfill, located in the town of Seneca, will close at the end of 2028.  The landfill contains 21,712,273 tons of municipal sludge, domestic waste, industrial waste, industrial sludge, construction and demolition debris, coal ash, contaminated soils, tires, shredded automobile fluff, asbestos, and glass.  From 2019-2023, the landfill produced an average of 22,775,583 gallons of leachate per year, the 8th largest volume in NYS. In addition to the currently operating cell, the Ontario County landfill also includes others that have already closed. Cumulatively, Ontario County projects that the landfill will generate an average 5,814,440 gallons of leachate per year for the thirty years after closure. The projection does not include an end date for leachate generation.
  3. Brookhaven Landfill, in Suffolk County, is expected to reach capacity in the second half of 2028.  The landfill’s permit expired in July 2026, but an application to DEC for a five-year extension is pending. The landfill’s most recent permit compliance report cites a total of 23,080,863 tons of ash, construction and demolition debris, and other waste, in two of the six total landfill cells. Totals for the other cells are not reported. Currently, Brookhaven landfill solely accepts ash from Covanta-owned incinerators that burn trash from across Long Island.  From 2019-2023, the landfill produced an average of 29,972,400 gallons of leachate per year, the 3rd largest volume in NYS.This landfill—“a symbol of systemic neglect”—is leaking a groundwater plume of leachate contaminated with perfluorooctanoic acid (PFOA), perfluorooctanesulfonic acid (PFOS), and 1,4-dioxane.  The decision to allow the ongoing disposal of this toxic leachate at sewage treatment plants—which are not equipped to remove these chemicals—is a choice to allow this pollution to spread even further.
  4. In 2025, Waste Connections, the owner of Seneca Meadows landfill, reported a remaining capacity of 1,221,831 tons of trash, less than the landfill consumed in 2024. Nonetheless, the landfill remains open, and rather than planning for closure, Waste Connections is pursing a 47-acre expansion. From 2019-2023, Seneca Meadows produced an average of 65,069,851 gallons of leachate per year, the largest volume in NYS. Waste Connections projects that Seneca Meadows landfill will generate a total of 63,255,270 gallons of leachate in the first four years after closure, followed by 9,385,990 gallons per year until thirty years post-closure. Waste Connections is not required to project beyond that time, so it is unclear when leachate production might end.

    Seneca Meadows landfill already contains 78,344,487 tons of trash from across New York and neighboring states, as well as construction and demolition debris, asbestos, industrial ash, and contaminated soil. People living in the neighboring communities of Seneca Falls and Waterloo “bear the consequences of a waste system that sends garbage from across the state to their doorstep.”

 

The Takeaway

DEC’s exemption for recently closed landfills could allow four of New York’s top-ten leachate producing landfills to avoid ever having to treat their contaminated leachate. Exempting closed and recently closed landfills from leachate treatment requirements is a mistake. Unless DEC revises its leachate management regulation, these landfills will dispose of millions of gallons of leachate at sewage treatment plants each year for decades, even as leachate treatment infrastructure comes online across the state. DEC is currently reviewing public comments and has until October 2027 to determine whether to make modifications.

 

Take action: Find your community’s landfill in New York State

Closing a landfill does not mean the pollution stops. Inactive and closed landfills can continue generating contaminated leachate for decades, much of which is transported to municipal sewage treatment plants that are not designed to remove many of its contaminants.

Find out whether your community has an inactive or closed landfill, and help make sure it isn’t left out of New York’s new leachate regulations.

  • Find out whether your community has an inactive landfill. Use the DEC’s Inactive Solid Waste Landfills map (see page 2 to find the “inactive landfill” map).  The map identifies known inactive landfill locations and provides facility information.
  • Find out who is responsible for it. Contact your town supervisor, city mayor, county government, or local solid waste authority. Ask who is responsible for post-closure care, where the leachate goes, and how much is generated.
  • Ask your local government to advocate for the landfill. Request that your municipality or county contact DEC and state legislators to support extending leachate treatment requirements to all landfills that collect leachate, including inactive and closed landfills, so they are no longer shipping untreated leachate to municipal sewage treatment plants and so they remain eligible for state funding once the new regulations are finalized.

A landfill’s closure should not mean the end of accountability. Communities deserve protection from ongoing pollution, and the means to address it.